Responses
Other responses
Jump to comment:
- Published on: 30 July 2018
- Published on: 17 July 2018
- Published on: 30 July 2018Reply to letter from Professor Gorodischer and colleagues on access to health care in Palestine
We thank Professor Gorodischer and colleagues for their comments on our article on Access for Health Care for children in Palestine.
Show More
We believe that politics and health are inextricably intertwined, and this view is shared by WHO in the Commission on Social Determinants of Health and by many commentators such as Professor David Hunter https://www.bmj.com/content/350/bmj.h1214
We consider that health is politically determined and this is evident in relation to public health issues such as the role of the tobacco industry in smoking, the role of the food industry in nutrition, and the relevance of pharmaceutical industry funding of politicians in determining health policy in the USA.
In relation to the connection between the occupation of Palestine and the health of its population, this is not controversial but is a fact, corroborated by WHO, UN, UNRWA, the Lancet and many non-governmental organisations such as Medical Aid to the Palestinians. For example -
http://www.emro.who.int/palestine-press-releases/2017/who-releases-lates...
https://www.un.org/press/en/2012/gapal1234.doc.htm
...Conflict of Interest:
None declared. - Published on: 17 July 2018Access to healthcare for children in Palestine
To the Editor,
BMJ OpenWe concur with the authors that the health care of Palestinian children is far from desirable, and for many of them, particularly in Gaza, has even tragic consequences.
However, the article has a clear political agenda, which is openly indicated in its last sentence. The authors chose to ignore the complex geopolitical circumstances in the area and the article is far from presenting an objective description of the situation.
The authors mention the following providers of medical care for Palestinian children: UNRWA, Non- governmental organizations, Palestinian Red Crescent and the private sector. They fail to mention Israel as a health care provider: although following the 1993 Oslo Accord, responsibilities of health care were transferred from Israel to the Palestinian territory, every year over 160,000 Palestinians from the occupied territories receive medical treatment in Israel 1,2. Prior to the year 2005, when the Palestinian Authority took over the Gaza administration, pediatricians from the Gaza Al-ShifaHospital came to the Soroka University Medical Center Pediatric Department in Beer-Sheva, Israel, for various periods of professional update, and pediatricians from the Israeli hospital periodically joined clinical rounds at the Al-Shifa Hospital Pediatric Department; often mutual friendly professional relations developed among pediatricians of both hospitals.
Show More
We refrain from debating here the authors...Conflict of Interest:
None declared.