Table 4

Comparison of family caregivers’ PAT scores from other paediatric populations with this study

StudyPopulationUniversal n (%)Targeted n (%)Clinical n (%)Mean PAT score95% CI of the differenceP value
Verma et al (this study),
n=136
Children with medical complexity61 (45%)60 (44%)15 (11%)1.17
Reader et al,
n=13636
Sickle cell disease63 (46%)54 (40%)19 (14%)1.150.16 to 0.200.8
Sharkey et al,
n=26237
CancerNRNRNR1.020.00 to 0.300.05
Tsumura et al,
n=11738
CancerNRNRNR1.45−0.48 to 0.0.80.006
Filigno et al,
n=15439
Cystic fibrosis80 (52%)63 (41%)11 (7%)1.000.00 to 0.340.05
Kapa et al,
n=21740
CraniofacialNRNRNR0.910.10 to 0.420.001
Law et al,
n=23541
Headache134 (57%)82 (35%)19 (8%)0.990.04 to 0.330.02
Rocque et al,
n=4042
Brain tumour24 (60%)15 (38%)1 (2%)0.890.03 to 0.520.03
Pai et al,
n=14043
Stem cell transplant76 (54%)42 (30%)22 (16%)1.14−0.15 to 0.210.7
Schulte et al,
n=9544
CancerNRNRNR0.840.14 to 0.52<0.001
Crerand et al,
n=21745
Craniofacial130 (60%)70 (32%)17 (8%)0.910.11 to 0.41<0.001
Ernst et al
n=19746
Disorders of sexual development130 (66%)55 (28%)12 (6%)0.860.16 to 0.46<0.001
Kazak et al,
n=39447
Cancer246 (62%)106 (27%)42 (11%)0.970.06 to 0.340.005
Cousino et al,
n=5648
Heart transplant33 (59%)17 (30%)6 (11%)0.960.02 to 0.440.08
Phan et al,
n=10031
Obesity7 (27%)17 (65%)2 (8%)1.20−0.20 to 0.140.7
Woods and Ostrowski-Delahanty
n=12749
HeadacheNRNRNR1.12−0.12 to 0.220.6
Clapin et al,
n=4950
Type 1 diabetesNRNRNR1.000.07 to 0.410.2
Pierce et al,
n=6751
Cancer42 (63%)21 (31%)4 (6%)0.900.06 to 0.480.01
McCarthy et al,
n=8952
Cancer51 (57%)34 (38%)4 (5%)1.00−0.01 to 0.350.07
Sint Nicolaas et al,
n=11753
Cancer77 (66%)34 (29%)6 (5%)0.800.20 to 0.54<0.001
Pai et al,
n=4230
Inflammatory bowel disease27 (64%)15 (36%)0 (0%)0.770.21 to 0.59<0.001
Barrera et al,
n=6722
Cancer40 (60%)21 (31%)6 (9%)NR
Hearps et al,
n=3923
Congenital heart disease24 (62%)14 (36%)1 (2%)0.810.14 to 0.580.001
Karlson et al,
n=21929
Sickle cell disease109 (50%)80 (36%)30 (14%)1.12−0.11 to 0.210.5
Pai et al,
n=4524
Kidney transplantNRNRNR0.98−0.06 to 0.440.1
Kazak et al,
n=5033
Cancer36 (72%)12 (24%)2 (4%)0.760.20 to 0.62<0.001
McCarthy et al,
n=22034
Cancer147 (67%)52 (24%)21 (9%)0.930.21 to 0.51<0.001
Alderfer et al,
n=10235
Cancer51 (50%)42 (41%)9 (9%)NR
Pai et al,
n=20527
Cancer122 (59%)65 (32%)18 (9%)1.02−0.01 to 0.310.07
  • P values were obtained by performing independent t-tests to compare each study with the current study; p values were corrected using the Šidák correction for multiple comparisons.

  • .NR, not reported; PAT, Psychosocial Assessment Tool.