Discussion
To the researchers’ knowledge, this is Bangladesh’s first comprehensive research evaluating ophthalmological changes of paediatric CKD patients. Since the study institution was a specialist tertiary care hospital, 22.8% and 41.3% of patients sent from other hospitals had stage V and stage VD CKD. The most common cause of CKD was congenital abnormalities of the kidney and urinary tracts (CAKUT), which includes hypoplastic kidneys and obstructive uropathies. Our findings support the global consensus that infections and CAKUT cause most paediatric CKD.23 We also found that CAKUT is the leading cause of CKD in children in South Asia also, including India,24 Pakistan25 and Nepal.26 Due to a lack of diagnostic facilities, CAKUT was less common in Bhutan.27
Our research used clinical and laboratory parameters to correlate with CKD classifications. SBP and DBP increased significantly with CKD progression. Hypertension is the primary clinical indicator of CKD, and higher levels suggest a worse prognosis.28 Mean haemoglobin, eGFR, serum creatinine, urea, calcium, phosphate, calcium-phosphate product and parathyroid hormone correlated significantly with CKD advancement. Value changes in our study indicate accelerating CKD and may indicate deteriorating prognosis.29 30
Based on visual acuity, 29 patients (31.5%) in our study exhibited visual impairment, with 20 (69.0%) having CKD V. This association was statistically significant and suggests advanced-stage patients with CKD experience greater vision impairment. A complete assessment of ocular health requires consideration of the cornea, lens and retina as well as decreasing visual acuity.31 15 of 29 visually impaired patients had HR as their primary cause. This group had 14 (93.3%) stage VD patients. This finding supports Nusinvoici et al’s5 finding that retinopathy severity is correlated with renal impairment. Additionally, eGFR values below 30 mL/min/1.73/m2 triple the risk of retinopathy.5 Furthermore, CKD resulting from chronic glomerulonephritis caused a posterior subcapsular cataract in one patient, impairing vision. Another research of adult patients with CKD identified maculopathy to be the main cause of visual impairment.12
Progression in CKD cause increasingly severe ophthalmological symptoms. Most (15, 79.0%) of the 19 patients with eyelid oedema were in CKD V and VD stages. Our findings match Mansour et al’s,4 who found eyelid oedema in 56.8% of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) patients. 56 patients (60.9%) had conjunctival pallor, indicating clinically evident anaemia and low haemoglobin. These findings align with Thulasidas and Amin,32 who found conjunctival pallor in 56.9% of patients with CKD. 9 (9.98%) stage VD patients reported dry eyes. Dry, red and irritated eyes are common in ESRD patients due to an altered blink reflex, shortened tear breakup times and decreased goblet cell density. CKD’s high vitamin A levels further accelerate the transition from secretory conjunctival mucosa to non-secreting keratinised epithelium.33 Akinci et al34 observed 15.8% of paediatric CKD patients had dry eye symptoms, matching our findings. In addition, El-Ghany et al13 identified dry eyes in 6.7% of haemodialysis patients compared with early CKD. One patient with chronic glomerulonephritis-related CKD stage VD and long-term steroid therapy had a posterior subcapsular cataract. A study also found 4.7% cataracts in paediatric ESRD patients with CKD VD due to CKD and dialysis complications.35 Stage VD CKD patients had an average intraocular pressure (IOP) of 12.8 mm Hg and an SD of 2.5. This measurement is within the usual 12-to-22-mm Hg IOP range. The finding matches with other studies. Both Mansour et al4 and Thulasidas and Amin32 found that the IOP of the study populations was 12.68±1.92 mm Hg and 13.4±2.2 mm Hg, respectively.
Conjunctival congestion was strongly correlated with serum phosphate and calcium phosphate levels in seven individuals (7.6%), six of whom were in stage VD. Calcium phosphate product buildup in the cornea and conjunctiva surpasses their solubility limit and causes persistent inflammatory changes, resulting in conjunctival congestion.9 36 In 2016, Malleswari and Rahmathunnisa37 found conjunctival congestion in 25.6% of haemodialysis patients with CKD. The medical goal for dialysis patients is to keep calcium-phosphate below 55 mg/dL .9
The most important results that potentially threaten vision in advanced CKD are posterior segment abnormalities. 45.7% of our patients had hypertension, and 16.3% had HR. All HR cases were in CKD VD patients. HR is rarer in children than adults, although renal insufficiency considerably increases it.38 The possible explanation for the connection between retinopathy and kidney function could be that retinal microvascular abnormalities resulting from hypertension, inflammation, and other processes may share a common pathophysiological link in the development and progression of CKD.37 In a study by El-Ghany et al,13 13.3% of Egyptian paediatric patients with CKD developed retinal abnormalities. Diabetes was common in ESRD adult research populations.4 However, none of the study participants had diabetes.
Ahsan et al39 found a strong link between low haemoglobin, high blood pressure, severe eGFR decline, and retinopathy risk. We also found that stage VD haemodialysis patients had high blood pressure, low haemoglobin and low eGFR. Comparing patients in different stages of CKD, these differences were significant (p<0.001). Most patients with HR were among haemodialysis group. Moreover, retinopathy patients had substantially low haemoglobin and eGFR. A strong correlation (p<0.001) was found between serum phosphate and calcium-phosphate product in HR patients. Increased blood phosphate levels may cause calcification in medium and large blood vessels, causing endothelial dysfunction and vascular disease in CKD patients. Retinopathy severity in CKD patients was independently associated to blood phosphate levels.40 Serum calcium and phosphate are also predictive markers for chronic renal disease-related ocular symptoms.39 CKD often causes secondary hyperthyroidism, which is exacerbated by mineral metabolism disruption. Therefore, these issues must be monitored routinely.
Limitations
This study had some limitations. It was a hospital-based study with no national sample. Due to COVID-19, sample size was limited. Additionally, the study did not assess intraobserver variation. Patients’ ophthalmological changes could not be assessed more extensively due to the study’s cross-sectional nature. Another limitation of our study is that Snellen’s criterion was translated to logMAR for visual acuity measurements. Scientifically, this conversion is imperfect since the two scales lack equivalent steps. This may have incorporated flaws into our data, affecting the precision of our visual acuity findings. Future study should consider using a single, uniform visual acuity test to avoid such differences. Expressing blood pressure in z-scores would have provided a more standardised comparison across different age groups. As a result, the observed increase in blood pressure may partially reflect the fact that advanced CKD stages are more common in older children, who naturally have higher normal blood pressure values.