Table 1

Summary of included publications, with authors and country, study type, target population, robot type and purpose (note: n/a = not applicable)

Source and countryStudy typeTarget populationRobot(s) and sourcePurpose of robot
Cheetham et al, Canada33 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenPEBBLES Telbotics Inc (Canada)Telepresence (connect hospitalised children to their classroom, support academic and social tasks)
Fels et al, Canada34 Case studyChildren who cannot physically attend schoolPEBBLES Telbotics Inc (Canada)Telepresence (connect ill child to school/education, be a physical representation of the child, support academic and social tasks)
Kimura et al, Japan35 Feasibility studyHospitalised childrenAIBO, Necoro cat, Capriro, and other interactive animal soft-toys
Sony (Japan), Omron (Japan), Bandai (Japan)
Companion (improve mood and quality of life)
Goris et al, Belgium36 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenProbo, PrototypeInform, support, comfort
Looije et al, the Netherlands28 Experimental design (mixed design)Diabetes, obesity and coeliaciCat, Phillips Electronics (the Netherlands)Motivator, educator, companion/buddy
Saldien et al, Belgium37 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenProbo, PrototypeEntertain, communicate, provide medical assistance
Goris et al, Belgium38 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenProbo, PrototypeEntertain/play, communicate/inform, provide medical assistance/comfort
Marti et al, Italy21 Technical development and feasibility studyDisabilities (autistic, motor impaired, intellectual disability)IROMEC, PrototypeSupport and stimulate play in educational/therapeutic settings
Marti et al, Italy, Austria, Spain, the Netherlands and UK39 Technical developmentDisabilities (autistic, motor impaired, intellectual disability)IROMEC, PrototypeCompanion (engage child in social interactions, empower discovery of a range of play styles)
Marti et al, Italy, Austria, Spain, the Netherlands and UK40 Technical developmentDisabilities (autistic, motor impaired, intellectual disability)IROMEC, PrototypeCompanion (engage child in social interactions, empower discovery of a range of play styles)
Bernd et al, the Netherlands18 Single-subject designIntellectual disabilitiesIROMEC, PrototypeSupport play in an occupational therapy intervention
Böhm et al, Austria41 Technical developmentDisabilitiesIROMEC, PrototypeSupport and stimulate play
Saldien et al, Belgium42 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenProbo, PrototypeInteract with hospitalised children
Díaz et al, Spain15 Feasibility studyHospitalised childrenNAO and Pleo Softbank robotics (Japan), Innvo labs (Hong Kong)Companion (improve quality of life)
Klein et al, the Netherlands43 Single-subject designDevelopmental disabilitiesIROMEC, PrototypeSupport play in an occupational therapy intervention
Lehmann et al, UK16 Experimental design (within subjects)Cognitive disabilitiesKASPAR and IROMEC, PrototypeEngage in play, facilitate social interaction, facilitate cognitive and social development
Lu et al, USA44 Technical development and feasibility studyDiabetesLego Mindstorm NXT
Lego (Denmark)
Companion/pet (reduce anxiety and fear)
Ros Espinoza et al, Italy45 Discussion paperDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Companion, instructor, playmate (engage child and support self-management, interact with child)
Ros et al, Italy46 Technical development and feasibility studyHospitalised childrenNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Exercise demonstrator, motivator, companion, help develop social skills
Saint-Aimé et al, France20 Technical development and feasibility studyHospitalised children/vulnerable childrenEmi, PrototypeCompanion (provide comfort)
Csala et al, Hungary47 Technical development and feasibility studyHospitalised children (bone-marrow transplant)NAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Companion (provide motivation and joy)
Looije et al, the Netherlands29 Experimental design (within subjects)Diabetes and other chronic conditionsNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Education companion
Nalin et al, Italy48 Discussion paperDiabetesn/an/a
Barco et al, Spain49 Study proposalTraumatic brain injuryLEGO Mindstorm NXT, Lego (Denmark)Cognitive rehabilitation (run activities, monitor performance), pet
Besio et al, Italy19 Feasibility studyDisabilitiesIROMEC, PrototypeEngage child in play
Calderita et al, Spain50 Feasibility studyUpper limb motor deficits (cerebral/brachial plexus palsy)Ursus, PrototypeTherapy tool (playmate; exercise coach, engagement, measure and record data)
Csala et al, Hungary51 Feasibility studyHospitalised children (bone-marrow transplanted)NAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Companion (provide motivation and joy)
De Greef et al, theNetherlands52 Case studyDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Interact with children
Okita, USA26 Experimental designHospitalised childrenParo, Paro robots (Japan)Companion (reduce anxiety and pain)
Ryu et al, Korea53 Technical developmentChildren who cannot attend schoolRobot under development, PrototypeTelepresence (connect ill child to school/education, reduce social isolation)
Alemi et al, Iran24 Experimental designCancerNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy assistant (information, reduce distress)
Baroni et al, Italy54 Interview/focus groupsDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Companion/peer (support and assist self-management)
Calderita et al, Spain55 Technical development and feasibility studyNeurorehabilitationTHERAPIST, PrototypeTherapy tool (playmate; coach, engagement, measure and record data)
Fridin et al, Israel27 Technical development and feasibility studyCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy coach/exercise demonstrator (motivation, encouragement, feedback)
Kozyavkin et al, Ukraine56 Feasibility studyCerebral palsyKineTron, Robotis (South Korea)Exercise demonstrator/coach (motivate and encourage)
Kruijff-Korbayová et al, Italy30 Experimental design (between subjects)DiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Provide long-term support, improve diabetes self-management
Lewis et al, UK57 Technical developmentDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Improve diabetes management (confront child, bond with child to increase motivation and engagement)
Malik et al, Malaysia58 Technical development and study proposalCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy tool (exercise demonstrator, motivator, companion to improve quality of life)
Malik et al, Malaysia59 Study proposalCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy tool (exercise demonstration, motivation, companion)
Messias et al, Portugal60 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenMOnarCH, PrototypeEdutainment
Özkul et al, Turkey61 Technical development and feasibility studyCommunication impairedNAO and Robovie, Softbank robotics (Japan), Vstone Ltd (Japan)Social peer/assistant (motivate, evaluate effort, give feedback, improve learning and recognition rate)
Vélez et al, Ecuador62 Technical development and feasibility studyLearning and psychosocial disabilitiesROBSNA, PrototypeInteract with children, stimulate play, support special education processes
Albo-Canals et al, Spain63 Technical development and feasibility studyHospitalised childrenPleo, Innvo labs (Hong Kong)Companion (reduce anxiety and stress)
Alotaibi et al, Saudi Arabia64 Technical developmentDiabetesAisoyl V5 Robot, Aisoy Robotics (Spain)Improve diabetes management (educate/give advice, motivate, monitor, companion)
Gonçalves et al, Portugal65 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenMOnarCH
Prototype
Interact with hospitalised children
Jeong et al, USA66 Experimental designHospitalised childrenHuggable, PrototypeMitigate stress, anxiety, pain
Köse et al, Turkey67 Feasibility studyCommunication impairedRobovie, Vstone Ltd (Japan)Social peer/assistant (motivate, evaluate effort, give feedback, improve learning and recognition rate)
McCarthy et al, Australia68 Technical development and study proposalRehabilitationNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Exercise demonstrator, motivator, distractor, monitoring aid
Rabbitt et al, USA31 Experimental designDisruptive behaviour problemsn/aAdminister cognitively based treatment
Rahman et al, Malaysia69 Feasibility studyCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Exercise demonstrator (motivate and encourage)
Alemi et al, Iran25 Experimental designCancerNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy assistant (provide information, reduce distress)
Al-Taee et al, UK70 Feasibility studyDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Diabetes management (educate, motivate, monitor, companion)
Arnold, USA71 Technical developmentAnxietyEmobie, PrototypeCompanion, communication between children, parents, therapists
Bonarini et al, Italy72 Technical development and feasibility studyNeurodevelopmental disordersTeo, PrototypeTherapy-driven game-based activities; free play
Børsting et al, Norway73 Feasibility studyMyalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndromeRobot-avatars, PrototypeTelepresence (connect ill child to school/education, reduce social isolation, be a physical representation of the child)
Cañamero et al, Italy74 Discussion paperDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Improve diabetes management (educate/give advice, motivate, monitor, companion)
Díaz-Boladeras et al, Spain75 Technical development and feasibility studyHospitalised childrenPleo, Innvo labs (Hong Kong)Companion (alleviate anxiety, loneliness, stress)
Larriba et al, Spain22 Technical developmentHospitalised childrenPleo, Innvo labs (Hong Kong)Reduce pain and anxiety during hospitalisation
Looije et al, the Netherlands17 Feasibility studyDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Self-management, educational activities, interact with child
Malik et al, Malaysia76 Feasibility studyCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy coach/exercise demonstrator (motivation)
Martí Carillo et al, Australia23 Feasibility studyCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Exercise demonstrator; motivator, companion
Meghdari et al, Iran77 Technical developmentCancerDr Arash, PrototypeInteract with hospitalised children and improve quality of life
Neerincx et al, Italy and the Netherlands78 Feasibility studyDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Improve diabetes management
Robles-Bykbaev et al, Ecuador79 Technical development and experimental designDisabilities and communication disordersSPELTRA, PrototypeSpeech-language therapy tool (exercises, recreational activities, register patient information and results, remote support)
Sequeira et al, Portugal80 Discussion paperSocially difficult environmentsMOnarCH, PrototypeEdutainment
Swift-Spong et al, USA32 Experimental designOverweightNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Exercise buddy
Ullrich et al, Germany81 Technical development and interview/focus groupsChildren in waiting room prior to medical visitNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Companion (stimulation, empathy, positive coping)
Yasemin et al, Turkey82 Experimental designDentalIRobi, Yujin Robot (South Korea)Distract, entertain, relax, reduce anxiety and pain
Blanson Henkemans et al, the Netherlands83 Discussion paperDiabetesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Improve self-management, interact with children in educational activities, provide emotional support
Blanson Henkemans et al, the Netherlands14 Randomised controlled trial (between subjects)Diabetes and other chronic diseasesNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Improve diabetes management (education, educate, provide pleasure, motivate)
Gelsomini et al, Italy84 Technical developmentNeurodevelopmental disordersPuffy, PrototypeCompanion (support education and therapeutic interventions, provide multisensory experience)
Martí Carillo et al, Australia85 Technical development and feasibility studyCerebral palsyNAO, Softbank robotics (Japan)Therapy tool (exercise demonstration, motivation, companion)
Van den Heuvel et al, the Netherlands86 Feasibility studyPhysical disabilitiesIROMEC, PrototypeSupport play