Table 4

Included and excluded patient cases in the Delphi process

Patient casesRound 1
Median score (IQR)
Round 2
Median score (IQR)
Decision
Child with asthmatic bronchitis who has responded to treatment with β2-agonists equivalent to adequate saturation (saturation has been adequate all the time) but with a high pulse rate.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
9 (7–9)Included
Child affected by pain with a high pulse rate. The cause of pain has been clarified.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
5 (2–7)6 (3–7)Included*
Child with febrile convulsions seen by a doctor; no suspected sepsis or meningitis and with a constant high pulse rate.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
7 (5–9)7 (5–8)Included†
Agitated child; crying/fidgety when staff are present but observed as calm and ‘happy’ when staff are not in the room.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
8 (6–9)8 (7–9)Included
Child with cancer who has received Solu-Medrol and afterwards has a high pulse rate.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
3 (1–6)3 (1–5)Excluded*
‘Child active in sports’ with a low pulse rate; the doctor has been made aware of the low pulse rate.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
9 (7–9)Included
Child who has been clinically stable for a longer period of time and who is stable just below or above a cut-off/threshold in the PEWS score.
The score can be lowered by 1 point for the current PEWS parameters (max 2 points in total).
7 (4–9)7 (5–8)Excluded*
Child treated with CPAP who has remained stable for a longer period of time and in this period the child has had stable high parameters.
Respiration rate, respiratory work or pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
5 (2–8)5 (2–7)Excluded*
Child with a high fever; antibiotic treatment has recently been initiated but has not yet taken sufficient effect.
The score for pulse rate and respiration rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
5 (2–8)5 (2–7)Included*
Child who is readmitted because the parents are concerned.
Maximum lowering by 2 points.
3 (1–7)3 (1–5)Excluded*
Child who is admitted because the parents are concerned.
Maximum lowering by 2 points.
3 (1–7)3 (1–5)Excluded*
Child with a high fever with a known focus on fever; the child is well.
The score for pulse rate and respiration rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
4 (1–7)5 (3–7)Excluded*
Patient with anorexia and a low pulse rate.
The score for pulse rate can be lowered (max 2 points).
5 (1–8)5 (2–7)Excluded*
Child with stable diabetes.
Maximum lowering by 2 points.
6 (3–9)5 (2–7)Excluded*
  • Non-consensus cases following round 2 were included or excluded due to the predefined criteria outlined in table 2.

  • *Included/excluded based on predefined criteria 2.

  • †Included/excluded based on predefined criteria 1.

  • CPAP, Continuous Positive Airway Pressure; PEWS, Paediatric Early Warning Score.