Abstract
Within the frameworks of shared decision-making and participation in healthcare, children’s ability to understand and appreciate information pertaining to illness and treatment is important. Physicians are mainly responsible for assessing decision-making capacity (DMC) but may encounter difficulties arising from the limited basis of evidence with regard to this concept in pediatrics. Three issues contributing to this paucity of knowledge on DMC of children can be identified: (1) conceptual blurriness and absence of clear terminology, (2) lack of validated tools to reliably assess DMC in the pediatric population, and (3) a need to include a developmental framework to understand DMC in children and adolescents. The aim of this paper is to examine these three issues and provide practical recommendations to advance the concept and its assessment in pediatrics as a step to ensuring children’s developmentally appropriate participation in healthcare. Finally, the paper highlights the ethical dimension of assessing DMC emphasizing the importance of physicians’ attitudes for the assessment process.
Conclusion: A detailed understanding of DMC is necessary to inform developmentally appropriate participation. In order to achieve this, pediatric practice needs to address challenges that are specific to providing healthcare for children, including conceptual issues, assessment, and aspects of child development.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The terms child, adolescent, and minor patients are used interchangeably to denominate patients who have not yet attained the legal age of majority.
In this article, we adopt the term capacity to denominate clinical decision-making ability (as opposed to usage of the word competence).
Abbreviations
- DMC:
-
Decision-making capacity
- UK:
-
United Kingdom
- US:
-
United States
Reference
Alderson P (1992) In the genes or in the stars? Children's competence to consent. J Med Ethics 18:119–124
Alderson P (1993) Children's consent to surgery. Open University Press, Buckingham
Alderson P (2003) Die Autonomie des Kindes: über die Selbstbestimmungsfähigkeit von Kindern in der Medizin. In: Wiesemann C, Dörries A, Wolfslast G, Simon A (eds) Das Kind als Patient-Ethische Konflikte zwischen Kindeswohl und Kindeswille. Campus Verlag, Frankfurt/Main, pp 28–47
Alderson P (2007) Competent children? Minors’ consent to health care treatment and research. Soc Sci Med 65:2272–2283
Alderson P, Sutcliffe K, Curtis K (2006) Children as partners with adults in their medical care. Arch Dis Child 91:300–303
American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics (1995) Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Pediatr 95:314–317
Appelbaum PS (2007) Assessment of patients' competence to consent to treatment. New Engl J Med 357:1834–1840
Appelbaum PS, Grisso T (1995) The MacArthur treatment competence study. I: mental illness and competence to consent to treatment. Law Hum Behav 19:105
Baines P (2011) Assent for children's participation in research is incoherent and wrong. Arch Dis Child 96:960–962
Bartholome WG (1995) Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Pediatrics 96:981–982
Beauchamp TL, Childress JF (2001) Principles of biomedical ethics. Oxford University Press, New York
Berg J (1996) Constructing competence: formulating standards of legal competence to make medical decisions. Rutgers L Rev 48:351–395
Bielby P (2005) The conflation of competence and capacity in English medical law: a philosophical critique. Med Healthc Philos 8:357–369
British Medical Association (2000) Involving children and assessing a child's competence. In: British Medical Association (ed) Consent, rights and choices in health care for children and young people. BMJ Books, London, pp pp 92–pp 103
Brook G (2000) Children’s competency to consent: a framework for practice. Paediatr Nurs 12:31–35
Büchner P (2003) Kinder und Kindheit in der Erwachsenengesellschaft - ein Blick auf die Stellung des Kindes aus kindheitssoziologischer Sicht. In: Wiesemann C, Dörries A, Wolfslast G, Simon A (eds) Das Kind als Patient-Ethische Konflikte zwischen Kindeswohl und Kindeswille. Campus Verlag, Frankfurt/New York, pp 11–27
Coyne I (2008) Children's participation in consultations and decision-making at health service level: a review of the literature. Intern J Nurs Stud 45:1682
Coyne I, Harder M (2011) Children’s participation in decision-making balancing protection with shared decision-making using a situational perspective. J Child Health Care 15:312–319
Coyne I, O'Mathúna DP, Gibson F, Shields L, Sheaf G (2013) Interventions for promoting participation in shared decision making for children with cancer. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
Deatrick J, Dickey S, Wright R, Beidler S, Cameron M, Shimizu H, Mason K (2003) Correlates of children's competence to make healthcare decisions. J Clin Ethic 14:152–163
Deutsch E, Spickhoff AM (2003) Arztrecht, Arzneimittelrecht, Medizinprodukterecht und Transfusionsrecht, 5th edn. Springer, Berlin
Didcock EA (2007) Issues of consent and competency in children and young people. Paediatr Child Health 17:425–428
Dunn L, Nowrangi M, Palmer B, Jeste D, Saks E (2006) Assessing decisional capacity for clinical research or treatment: a review of instruments. Am J Psychiatry 163:1323–1334
Etchells E, Darzins P, Silberfeld M, Singer PA, McKenny J, Naglie G, Katz M, Guyatt GH, Molloy DW, Strang D (1999) Assessment of patient capacity to consent to treatment. J Gen Intern Med 14:27–34
Etchells E, Sharpe G, Elliott C, Singer PA (1996) Bioethics for clinicians: 3. Capacity. Can Med Assoc J 155:657–661
Fitten LJ, Lusky R, Hamann C (1990) Assessing treatment decision-making capacity in elderly nursing home residents. J Am Geriatr Soc 38:1097–1104
Freeman M (2005) Rethinking Gillick. Int'l J Child Rts 13:201–217
Gabe J, Olumide G, Bury M (2004) 'It takes three to tango': a framework for understanding patient partnership in paediatric clinics. Soc Sci Med 59:1071
UN General Assembly (1989) Convention on the rights of the child. Available via http://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b38f0.html. Accessed 07 May 2014
Grisso T, Appelbaum PS (1995) The MacArthur treatment competence study. III: abilities of patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatments. Law Hum Behav 19:149–174
Grisso T, Appelbaum PS (1998) Why competence is important: the doctrine of informed consent. In: Grisso T, Appelbaum PS (eds) Assessing competence to consent to treatment: a guide for physicians and other health professionals. University Press, Oxford, pp 1–15
Grisso T, Appelbaum PS, Mulvey EP, Fletcher K (1995) The MacArthur treatment competence study. II: measures of abilities related to competence to consent to treatment. Law Hum Behav 19:127–148
Grisso T, Vierling L (1978) Minors' consent to treatment: a developmental perspective. Prof Psychol 9:412–427
Hein I, Troost P, Lindeboom R, de Vries M, Zwaan C, Lindauer R (2012) Assessing children’s competence to consent in research by a standardized tool: a validity study. BMC Pediatr 12:156–163
Hickey K (2007) Minors' rights in medical decision making. JONAS Healthc Law Ethics Regul 9:100–104
Hinds PS, Drew D, Oakes LL, Fouladi M, Spunt SL, Church C, Furman WL (2005) End-of-life care preferences of pediatric patients with cancer. JCO 23:9146–9154
Joffe S, Fernandez CV, Pentz RD, Ungar DR, Mathew NA, Turner CW, Alessandri AJ, Woodman CL, Singer DA, Kodish E (2006) Involving children with cancer in decision-making about research participation. J Pediatr 149:862–868, e861
Kon AA (2010) The shared decision-making continuum. JAMA 304:903–904
Koocher GP, DeMaso DR (1990) Children's competence to consent to medical procedures. Pediatrician 17:68–73
Kuther TL (2003) Medical decision-making and minors: issues of consent and assent. Adolescence 38:343–358
Larcher V, Hutchinson A (2010) How should paediatricians assess Gillick competence? Arch Dis Child 95:307–311
Lee KJ, Havens PL, Sato TT, Hoffman GM, Leuthner SR (2006) Assent for treatment: clinician knowledge, attitudes, and practice. Pediatrics 118:723–730
Leikin SL (1983) Minors' assent or dissent to medical treatment. J Pediatr 102:169–176
Leikin S (1993) Minors' assent, consent, or dissent to medical research. IRB: Ethic Hum Res 15:1–7
Levy MDL, Larcher V, Kurz R (2003) Informed consent/assent in children. Statement of the ethics working group of the Confederation of European Specialists in Paediatrics (CESP). Eur J Pediatr 162:629–633
Lo B (1990) Assessing decision‐making capacity. JLME 18:193–201
Mårtenson EK, Fägerskiöld AM (2007) A review of children’s decision-making competence in health care. J Clin Nurs 17:3131–3141
McCabe MA (1996) Involving children and adolescents in medical decision making: developmental and clinical considerations. J Pediatr Psychol 21:505–516
Michel M (without date) Der Fall Ashley oder von Grenzen und Massstäben elterlicher Entscheidungskompetenz. Available via http://www.academia.edu/1452154/Der_Fall_Ashley_oder_von_Grenzen_und_Massstaben_elterlicher_Entscheidungskompetenz. Accessed 20 Feb 2014
Miller VA, Drotar D, Kodish E (2004) Children's competence for assent and consent: a review of empirical findings. Ethic Behav 14:255–295
Nebendahl M (2009) Selbstbestimmungsrecht und rechtfertigende Einwilligung des Minderjährigen bei medizinischen Eingriffen. MedR Medizinrecht 27:197–205
Peter C (2008) Die einwilligung von minderjährigen in medizinische eingriffe. Schweiz Ärzteztg 89:1539–1540
Peters S (2013) Wenn Kinder anderer Meinung sind-Die ethische Problematik von Kindeswohl und Kindeswille in der Kinder-und Jugendmedizin. MD, Universität Göttingen, http://hdl.handle.net/11858/00-1735-0000-0001-BBDB-8
Scherer D (1988) The capacities of minors to exercise voluntariness in medical decisions. Law Hum Behav 15:431–449
Scherer DG, Reppucci ND (1988) Adolescents' capacities to provide voluntary informed consent: the effects of parental influence and medical dilemmas. Law Hum Behav 12:123–140
Schlam L, Wood JP (2000) Informed consent to the medical treatment of minors: law and practice. Health Matrix 10:141–174
Shaw M (2001) Competence and consent to treatment in children and adolescents. Adv Psychiatr Treat 7:150–159
Sigman GS, O'Connor C (1991) Exploration for physicians of the mature minor doctrine. J Pediatr 119:520–525
Spaak T (2005) The concept of legal competence. Leg Theory Philo Law
Spencer GE (1999) Children's competency to consent: an ethical dilemma. J Child Health Care 4:117–122
Spinetta JJ, Masera G, Jankovic M, Oppenheim D, Martins AG, Arush B, Weyl M, van Dongen-Melman J, Epelman C, Medin G (2003) Valid informed consent and participative decision-making in children with cancer and their parents: a report of the SIOP working committee on psychosocial issues in pediatric oncology. Med Pediatr Oncol 40:244–246
Trachsel M, Mitchell C, Biller-Andorno N (2013) Decision-making incapacity at the end of life: conceptual and ethical challenges. Bioet Forum 6:26–30
Vollmann J (2003) Konzeptionelle und methodische Fragen bei der Feststellung der Einwilligungsfähigkeit bei Kindern. In: Wiesemann C, Dörries A, Wolfslast G, Simon A (eds) Das Kind als Patient-Ethische Konflikte zwischen Kindeswohl und Kindeswille. Campus Verlag, Frankfurt/New York, pp 48–58
Weithorn LA, Campbell SB (1982) The competency of children and adolescents to make informed treatment decisions. Child Dev 53:1589–1598
Whitney SN, Ethier AM, Frugé E, Berg S, McCullough LB, Hockenberry M (2006) Decision making in pediatric oncology: who should take the lead? The decisional priority in pediatric oncology model. J Clin Oncol 24:160–165
Wölk F (2001) Der minderjährige patient in der ärztlichen behandlung bedingungen für die wahrnehmung des selbstbestimmungsrechts von minderjährigen bei medizinischen eingriffen. MedR Medizinrecht 19:80–89
Wright B, Aldridge J, Wurr K, Sloper T, Tomlinson H, Miller M (2008) Clinical dilemmas in children with life-limiting illnesses: decision making and the law. Palliat Med 23:238–247
Funding
The authors acknowledge the financial support provided by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF), National Research Programme 67 “End of Life,” Grant-No. 406740_139283/1, the Botnar Grant of the University of Basel, and the HEMMI-Stiftung, Basel.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by Beat Steinmann
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ruhe, K.M., Wangmo, T., Badarau, D.O. et al. Decision-making capacity of children and adolescents—suggestions for advancing the concept’s implementation in pediatric healthcare. Eur J Pediatr 174, 775–782 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00431-014-2462-8
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00431-014-2462-8